Vincent Kompany was one of three names on the last shortlist Pep Guardiola drew up for Manchester City, Karl-Heinz Rummenigge has revealed.

The Bayern Munich executive and former Chairman told how Uli Hoeneß and he agreed that Rummenigge should telephone Guardiola before appointing Kompany in 2024. What came back was an endorsement that stopped the conversation dead.

He said, 'One hundred per cent. Absolutely.'

Rummenigge added that he had never heard Guardiola speak so highly of another person as he did of Kompany. The two men talked for an hour and a half. Guardiola had known the Belgian as a player and captain at City, and had also experienced him as a fellow coach in England.

A shortlist that never became a vacancy

City, according to Rummenigge, had asked Guardiola to put together a shortlist in case he ever decided to leave. Kompany featured among the three candidates on the last one he compiled. Guardiola stayed until the summer of 2026, when he left the Etihad Stadium. Enzo Maresca, the former Leicester City and Chelsea manager, inherited the job.

Before any of that, Bayern had to talk themselves into it. Kompany arrived at the Allianz Arena in 2024 fresh from relegation out of the Premier League with Burnley, having won the Championship at a record-breaking pace the season before. Rummenigge, a two-time Ballon d'Or winner, was not immediately sold.

Max Eberl, Bayern's Director of Sport, raised Kompany's name at an internal meeting. Rummenigge asked him: 'Are you sure?' His reply was blunt enough.

I replied, 'He's just been relegated from the Premier League.'

Bayern had never appointed a coach who had just been relegated, in the Bundesliga or anywhere else. They discussed for a long time whether they had the courage to take that step. Memories of the bruising campaign that saw the trophy go to Bayer Leverkusen were still fresh.

The faith was repaid

Kompany's first season delivered the Bundesliga title back. His second retained it. The raised eyebrows of 2024 look rather quaint now.

For City supporters, the detail that lingers is the shortlist. Kompany, a four-time Premier League title-winning captain and one of the defining figures of the club's modern era, cut his managerial teeth at Anderlecht before Burnley. At 40, he has two Bundesliga crowns and a reference from Guardiola that Rummenigge describes as unlike anything he has heard.

The succession went to Maresca. The road not taken remains on the record.