Manchester City's decision to bench James Trafford for Gianluigi Donnarumma early last season is looking increasingly questionable.
Trafford, who started three matches for City last season, was replaced by Donnarumma after the Italian arrived from Paris Saint-Germain. Following that change, Trafford saw action in just one more match before leaving to join Leeds.
Donnarumma has remained the top keeper in Manchester, but his performances have raised eyebrows. He has allowed 13 goals in 10 matches, with a save percentage of 65.8 — a career-worst. His 1.3 goals per 90 minutes is also a personal low, dwarfing his previous worst of 1.18 with Milan a decade ago.
Trafford, meanwhile, is playing quite well for Leeds. He has allowed eight goals in 10 matches and boasts a save percentage of 82.2.
City's recent form has compounded the scrutiny. The Blues have lost three straight Premier League matches, and manager Enzo Maresca's unwillingness to stay anywhere close to the same XI has caused communication problems on the pitch. Maresca had wanted to bring in players like Enzo Fernandez, but the current issues extend beyond transfers.
For City fans, the sight of Trafford excelling at Leeds while Donnarumma struggles at the Etihad is a uncomfortable reminder of what might have been. The club's quick decision to bench Trafford now looks like a gamble that has backfired.






